I am fairly new to reading challenges so I am a little hesitant to make too many book commitments and then find myself not finishing them. So I decided on two challenges - The 2010 Debut Authors Challenge hosted by the Story Siren. Here is the link to my post about the Debut Authors Challenge alybee930.livejournal.com/5592.html
And the second challenge is The 10-10-10 Reading Challenge (Modified) - 101010reading.blogspot.com/
Modification of 10-10-10: Three books in each category rather than 10 books.
Please note: I am allowing overlap with the two challenges and where as the 2010 Debut Author Challenge is all Children and YA authors, this will include adult titles as well.
Mystery/Crime Fiction/Thriller
The First Rule by Robert Crais
Closed for the Season by Mary Downing Hahn
The Body Finder by Kimberly Derting (This may be a stretch to fit it in this category but I am leaving it for now. Still want to read it.)
Historical Fiction
Al Capone Shines My Shoes by Gennifer Choldenko
Fever 1793 by Laurie Halse Anderson
The Book Thief by Markus Zusak
Dystopian
The Hunger Games Book 3 by Suzanne Collins
The Scorch Trials (The Maze Runner Book 2) by James Dashner
The Line by Teri Hall
Fantasy (Vampires/Werewolves/Zombies/Faeries,etc.
13 to Life by Shannon Delany
Spell Hunter by R.J. Anderson
Graceling by Kristin Cashore
A Debut Author
The Secret Year by Jennifer R Hubbard
Sea by Heidi R Kling
Restoring Harmony by Joelle Anthony
A Classic Children's Book that I have never read
Blubber by Judy Blume
Harriet the Spy by Louise Fitzhugh
Old Yeller by Fred Gipson
A book that is being made into a movie
The Lightening Thief by Rick Riordan
How To Train Your Dragon by Cressida Cowell
Beastly by Alex Finn
A book about food/food central to the theme
The School of Essential Ingredients by Erica Bauermeister
My Life in France by Julia Child
Eat, Pray, Love by Elizabeth Gilbert
YA Realistic Fiction
WinterGirls by Laurie Halse Anderson
Struts and Frets by Jon Skovron
Absolutely, Maybe by Lisa Yee
A Book Where the Main Character has a disability
The Dark Days of Hamburger Halpin by Josh Berk
Harmonic Feedback by Tara Kelly
The Reinvention of Edison Thomas by Jacqueline Houtman
Well I think I am going to post what I have and try again tomorrow to add pictures.
- Location:my favorite corner
- Mood:
content
Back in October, I signed up for the Dystopian Challenge on Bart's Bookshelf. The goal was to read 4 Dystopian books by December 31st. When I first heard about the challenge, I thought "easy peasy" - four books in 2-1/2 months. What I didn't realize is that when I read a dystopian story it takes me weeks before I can read another one. So it actually was harder than I expected and I am actually about 1/2 a book short of the goal.
Here is my List of books and some quick thoughts:
The Maze Runner by James Dashner (on my original list to read):
This was on my fall list of anticipated books. It was released on October 6, 2009. I was excited to read the book but after seeing the book trailer I was somewhat spooked. However, at a book signing with the author (who is a super fabulous guy), he assured us that the trailer was "scarier" than the book. I went home and read the book that weekend. It was wonderful. I fell in love with Thomas and the other boys in the Glade. The Maze Runner made it to my top 5 YA books for 2009 and I eagerly anticipate the sequel.
Life As We Knew It by Susan Beth Pfeffer (not on my original list but on my secondary list):
Wow! I think I prefer dystopian stories that are set in the future and have their own world rather than ones that I can imagine happening today. Pfeffer's story was powerful and somewhat panic-inducing. As I watch the snow come down outside and enjoy the warmth of my home, I am glad I am not going through what her characters had to endure. Very dark but worth the read.
The Forest of Hands and Teeth by Carrie Ryan (not on my original list but on my secondary list):
Though the book is technically about zombies, it really isn't. The setting in some ways could have easily been anywhere in the past, present, or future. It is a story about love and living and the freedom to do both and what happens when a few try to control the whole and what one girl does to risk it all. Well written, powerful, and engaging from the beginning with just enough to scare you. Another top pick for 2009.
The Girl in the Arena by Lise Haines (on my original list):
I am currently reading this book and enjoying it. But alas...may run out of hours before finishing the book.
Read just prior to the challenge:
Catching Fire By Suzanne Collins
Just an amazing series and I can't wait until book 3 comes out in August/September of 2010.
Among the Hidden by Margaret Peterson Haddix
Haddix Shadow Children's series is the Hunger Games of the middle grade readers. I am about halfway through the 7 book series. It is wonderful and worth reading.
Thanks Bart's Bookshelf for your wonderful challenge!
- Location:a comfortable spot
- Mood:
content
At the beginning of this year, I decided that I needed to re-explore some of the things that energized me. One of those things was doing more pleasure reading. I began by doing a book club with my students which was a great excuse to combine “work reading” with fun since I thoroughly enjoy reading children’s and YA literature. Then in an effort to encourage my 8 year old niece’s budding interest in reading, I started exploring new books and book events to share with her. The results have been amazing, but that is for another blog post.
As summer approached, I decided to set a goal for myself as to how many books I would read this year. My goal was 50 books for 2009. I was feeling really bad about only setting my goal at reading 50 books this year but I set the goal in June and at that point I really hadn’t read that many books. As of the beginning of June I had read 9 books and one was a “did not finish” (DNF). So when I think about it, I actually did well. From June to December, I have read 58 books which includes one more DNF and a few adult novels as well. (Note: This does not include the numerous picture books that I read over that time as well since I didn’t think that should really count.)
Before sharing my favorites of 2009, I will say that it was good to read outside of my primary interest level. Typically when reading YA fiction, I chose from the fantasy/urban fantasy category. Thanks to so many people raving about new releases, I started reading lots of new authors and other categories including realistic fiction and a few graphic novels. Though I am still partial to YA urban fantasy, I was pleasantly surprised at some of the other stories that I read.
In finally reviewing all of the books that I read in 2009, I came up with my favorites list. All books were released in 2009 unless otherwise specified. If the pick was a series, the current book had to be released in 2009.
Favorite Paranormal Romance:
Beautiful Creatures by Kami Garcia and Margaret Stohl
Favorite Book About Werewolves:
Shiver by Maggie Stiefvater
Favorite Book About Zombies:
The Forest of Hands and Teeth by Carrie Ryan
Favorite YA Series:
Mortal Instruments Trilogy by Cassandra ClareFavorite Dystopian:
The Maze Runner by James Dashner tied with Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins
Favorite Middle Grade:
When You Reach Me by Rebecca Stead tied with SLOB by Ellen Potter
Favorite Middle Grade Series:
The Secret Series by Pseudonymous Bosch
Favorite Realistic YA Fiction:
Food, Girls, And Other Things I Can’t Have by Allan Zadoff
Favorite Book with a Character with a Disability:
Anything but Typical by Nora Raleigh Baskin
Favorite Picture Book:
The Seeing Stick by Jane Yolen (2009 release – with new illustrations the original was in 1977)Favorite Book Read in 2009 that was released before 2009:
The Adoration of Jenna Fox by Mary E. Pearson
Wishing everyone a Happy New Year and to great reading in 2010! I am upping my goal to 100 books next year. Oh man, the pressure is on...
Note: If you are interested in more of what I read in 2009, please refer to my two earlier posts.
- Location:A very uncomfortable chair
- Mood:
relaxed - Music:Everything's Right by Matt Wertz
Here are my thoughts on several 2009 releases... Thanks to Twitter, I discovered Kate Messner, a teacher and a writer. Before I even realized who she was, I had copied one of her School Library Journal (SLJ) articles for my teachers. The article was talking about Authors visiting schools via Skype. Since then she has been the source of great referrals for Middle Grade Fiction, ideas for using technology in the classroom, and even a great post on editing that I was able to use with my kids.
So the first two books are a nod to Kate (who you should go follow on Twitter @katemessner or on Facebook)...
1. The Brilliant Fall of Gianna Z by none other than Kate Messner, herself Now I tend to be partial to fantasy fiction and only pick realist fiction when I have to, but Gianna Z won me over. Messner did a fabulous job with making Gianna a very relate-able character, who I could relate to on so many different levels. And at times, I miss my New England roots and the changing seasons and while I read the book, I was able to escape to Vermont during my favorite season. When I did my plug for this book to my students, I had a wait list for children wanting to read it. Even a couple of my reluctant readers gave the book a "thumbs up" and one student said "I think Gianna Z was written just for me". Note: I am looking for someone to help me get a class set of these books. Unfortunately, I might have to wait until I find them in paperback.
2. Anything but Typical by Nora Raleigh Baskin Though not written by Messner, this was a book I discovered thanks to one of her tweets. I promptly ordered Baskin's Anything But Typical, a story told from the POV of a 12 year old boy with Autism. As the principal of a school with a significant number of students on the Autism Spectrum who are included in general education classes, I am always on the look out for good books on this topic. Once I finished reading this, not only did I recommend it to my students, but to parents, teachers, and anyone else that will listen to me. It does an exceptional job helping the reader understand what life is like living with Autism. For the past two weeks, I have read the story aloud to my sixth graders. They really got it and have been enjoying it. Some of the students have siblings on the Autism Spectrum and the book allowed them to feel more comfortable sharing stories about their own experiences. This is one book that I wish I had the budget to purchase one copy for each one of my staff, but I have purchased several copies for teachers to check out and read.
My next two choices are my current favorites for outstanding books in 2009. Thanks to my local Children's & YA book club, I stumbled upon When You Reach Me by Rebecca Stead and SLOB by Ellen Potter. Believe it or not they kind of work well together. Both books are set in New York City, both are realistic coming of age stories with a slight sci-fi twist or feel to them. Each story touched me on a deeply personal level for very different reasons. I won't say a ton about the books because I don't want to give any spoilers. However, I will say that though I had them both on my e-reader, I went out and bought hard copies for the classroom. And I think I will need to get more copies since the ones we have are always checked out. Additionally, I have given copies of both of these books as gifts.
Finally, the last of the 2009 new Middle Grade releases that I have read so far is Bobby vs. Girls (Accidentally) by Lisa Yee. This was just a fun read. Bobby is your typical fourth grade boy. He is completely oblivious to what is happening to girls and manages to unintentionally get all the girls in his class mad at him. To encourage students to do more writing, we recently held an essay contest among our fourth to sixth graders. The prize - a signed copy of Bobby vs. Girls (Accidentally). Let's just say I have a very happy student winner.
Some fun reads, though not released in 2009... The Name of This Book is Secret (first book in the Secret Series) by Pseudonymous Bosch James and the Giant Peach by Roald Dahl (How did I miss this book all these years?) Among the Hidden (first book in the Shadow Children Series) by Margaret Peterson Haddix Gregor the Overlander (first book in the Underlander Chronicles) by Suzanne Collins Magyk (first book in the Septimus Heap Series) by Angie Sage Well that's it for tonight, but I plan on doing a final wrap up on my favorites at the end of the year...
Note: I apologize in advance for any formatting issues...LiveJournal is giving me a hassle.
- Location:my favorite corner
- Mood:
exhausted - Music:Holiday songs - all types
My favorite series this year is without a doubt Cassandra Clare's Mortal Instrument Trilogy. If I didn't have a goal to read 50 books this year, I could have probably spent months just re-reading City of Bones, City of Ashes, and City of Glass. I loved that it was one of those series that once started I couldn't stop until I read every one of them. Now I am eagerly awaiting, Clare's new series and then the fourth book in the Mortal Instruments.
Sandwiched before and after the Mortal Instruments Trilogy were the Generation Dead books by Daniel Waters. An interesting twists on zombies. However, the teacher in me quickly saw ways of using the books to talk about differences with students. And now I am of course waiting for the third book in the series. Glad there is plenty to read in the interim.
Of course I needed to branch out and not just get stuck on a couple of series. So I decided to read Tithe by Holly Black; Great & Terrible Beauty by Libba Bray; Lament and Shiver by Maggie Stiefvater. I was awed by the world of the fey that Black so masterfully created. Bray’s sense of dialogue and ability to inject sass & humor in her 19th century main character was brilliant. The faerie world of Lament was vastly different than Shiver’s Minnesota werewolves but Stiefvater’s lyrical writing and enchanting characters cast their own magic.
Not stopping there, I discovered Mary E. Pearson’s The Adoration of Jenna Fox where teens and parents can agree on a book but for totally separate reasons. It still moves me and it has been months since I read it.
Next I discovered that I enjoyed books that I would never have picked up on my own but am thankful to my bookclub for making me read them. Cory Doctorow managed to make techno-babble understandable in Little Brother and Markus Zukus created a likable but unlikely hero in I am the Messenger.
September came and I finally caught up with Katniss, Gale, and Peeta in Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins, but James Dashner’s Maze Runner certainly provided some healthy competition in the area of Dystopian literature. Now if next fall could come quickly so I can read the sequels of each of those books.
In 2009, I discovered that not all realistic teen fiction is filled with over the top drama. Allen Zadoff’s Food, Girls, and Other Things I Can’t Have was fun, and heartwarming. And David Levithan’s Love is the Higher Law was insightful and touching as it sought to capture one of the many stories of 9/11.
Finally, Kami Garcia & Margaret Stohl lured me into their world of Beautiful Creatures which is currently in contention for my number one choice of 2009.
Next up: A look at my favorite Middle Grade Fiction that I read in 2009…Until then tell me what was your favorite.
- Location:my favorite corner
- Mood:
exhausted - Music:Holiday songs - all types
My challenge for 2010 in addition to reading another 50 books is to read at least 12 debut novels by YA or MG authors. The challenge is being hosted by The Story Siren (Kristi). You can join in on the challenge by popping over to her website. I have created a list of possible debut novels that I will be reading during 2010. Please note they are all books on my wishlist but I reserve the right to swap out titles.
My list of tentative books for the challenge:
Sea by Heidi R. Kling
The Secret Year by Jennifer R. Hubbard
Paranormalcy by Kiersten White
The Body Finder by Kimberly Derting
The Tension of Opposites by Kristina McBride
The Beautiful Between by Alyssa B. Sheinmel
Other by Karen Kincy
The Duff by Kody Keplinger
Hex Hall by Rachel Hawkins
The Reinvention of Edison Thomas by Jacqueline Houtman
Bleeding Violet by Dia Reeves
The Red Umbrella by Christina Diaz Gonzalez
A Most Improper Magick by Stephanie Burgis
Escaping the Tiger by Laura Manivong
The Dark Days of Hamburger Halpin by Josh Berk
Even if you don't want to join in on the full challenge, I would love everyone to consider reading at least one debut novel in 2010.
12/06/09 Update: Well as I continued to look into debut releases for 2010, I came across a few more that I would like to add to my list:
Thirteen to Life: A Werewolf's Tale by Shannon Delany
Leaving Gee's Bend by Irene Latham
Cinderella Society by Kay Cassidy
The Rise of Renegade X by Chelsea Campbell
The Mockingbirds by Daisy Whitney
Freaksville by Kitty Keswick
Shade by Jeri Smith-Ready

- Location:my favorite corner
- Mood:
mellow
Here is the review that I posted over at Young Adult Literature Review Blog (http://youngadultlitreviewblog.blogspot.cPages: 195
Reading Level: Ages 9 to 12 years
Over the years, I have shifted my reading preferences from more realistic fiction to fantasy fiction and suspense. Much of this switch can be attributed to working in a field where I deal with the harshness of reality on a daily basis. When I do find time for pleasure reading, I want to simply escape. However, after starting a book club for 4th-6th graders, I realized that I would be remiss if the only novels I recommended were part of the fantasy and science fiction genre.
I was attracted to Kate Messner’s The Brilliant Fall of Gianna Z. for several reasons. First, Messner is a middle school teacher. As an educator, I want to be able to encourage and support teachers who are writers. Second, though I currently live in Southern California, I grew up in New England and the story is set in the fall in Vermont. Third, I was looking for a realistic fiction story to share with my students in our book club.
Gianna (“Gee”) is a twelve year old girl who would rather be drawing pictures, or running trails than doing homework. The story opens with Gianna needing to finish a science project by the end of the week. Her ability to compete in the upcoming Sectionals for cross-country hinges on her ability to complete the project on time and obtain a passing grade. It appears that nearly everyone has been working on this science project for the past three weeks except for Gianna. With the support of her best friend Zig, Gee believes that she will be able to finish the task and then compete in Sectionals. However, as most of us know, real life can trip us up on the way to the finish line. Not only does Gee have to deal her archenemy, Bianca, trying to sabotage her efforts, but there are unexpected challenges at home that continue to interfere with Gee's reaching her goals.
Messner does a phenomenal job in making Gee, her friends, school and home life seem real. In many ways, Gee is a typical middle schooler who struggles with her school work, with budding emotions for her male best friend, and with the transformation of her family life due to her grandmother’s failing memory. Without giving too much of the story away, Gee’s quest to find 25 leaves and assemble them into a display for her science teacher becomes the metaphor for all of the changes and challenges that she is facing.
I loved the tender and fragile relationship between Gee and her grandmother. And as a teacher, I recognized in Gianna so many of my own students who struggle to attend and to conform to the system and structure called school. My only criticism was that Gianna’s perspective often times seemed more mature than I would expect from a 12 year old who leaned more towards being a creative free-spirit than the “I’ve had to grow up too fast” type of kid. Much of Gianna’s reactions and dialogue seemed fairly aligned with her character’s persona, but at times the narration which was from Gianna’s point of view seemed more adult like. However, I don’t believe that it takes away from the story and I would recommend the book to children and adults, especially for children who are dealing with a close family member whose health concerns are impacting the lives of other the family members.
Enjoy the fall, and find time to read a book…
-Aly
- Location:my favorite corner
- Mood:
content
Recently, Bart's Bookshelf put out a challenge to read up to 4 YA dystopian books between October 15, 2009 to December 31, 2009. Since I already had several dystopian books on my TBR pile, I decided to take up the challenge. The four books that I decided to read for the challenge are as follows: * The Maze Runner by James Dashner
* The Girl in the Arena by Lise Haines
* Unwind by Neal Shusterman
* Skinned by Robin Wasserman
Of course that still leaves me the rest of Margaret Peterson Haddix' Shadow Children's Series. I read the first 3 with my 8 year old niece this summer. I'm on book 4 and she just started book 5. And other dystopian books on my TBR list includes: The Forest of Hands and Teeth by Carrie Ryan; Genesis by Bernard Beckett; The Uglies by Scott Westerfeld; The Giver by Lois Lowry; and Life As We Knew It by Susan Beth Pfeffer.
Now of course, the biggest challenge, is finding time with a busy schedule to read all of those books but fortunately I have a couple of long weekends between October 15th and the end of the year. If worse comes to worse, it will be a dystopian read-a-thon. :-)
- Location:my favorite corner
- Mood:
melancholy
Pages: 391
Reading Level: Young Adult
In the fall of 2008, I discovered Suzanne Collin’s book Hunger Games. However it took me a couple of months to finally read the book. Even though it had gotten great reviews, I struggled with the concept of a book premise where teenagers were forced into a game where they were required to kill one another. Yet, once I finally picked up the book and started reading it, I couldn’t put it down. It was one of those “disturbing in a good way” books. To my amazement, I ranked the Hunger Games as the top book I had read in 2008. But then began the wait for the sequelCatching Fire.
At the end of the Hunger Games, main character Katniss Everdeen had found a way to not only win but to also keep fellow tribute, Peeta Mellark alive as well. Her behavior was viewed as an act of rebellion, and upon her return home, life was not as she expected. Her relationship with her best friend Gale is strained. Peeta, her fellow victor, is ignoring her and there are rumors of a rebellion rising as a result of her and Peeta’s actions in the arena. So what’s a 17 year old girl to do when the Capital feels that her actions were an act of defiance, and she has become a symbol of a potential uprising?
Suzanne Collin’s second book in the Hunger Games Trilogy picks up shortly after the end of the first novel. With this installment, Collins again contrasts the shallow, arrogant, self-centeredness of the Capital’s leaders and residents with the struggles, poverty, and oppression of the residents of the 12 Districts. Sinister President Snow informs Katniss that he is aware of her feelings for Gale and that if she doesn’t want it to seem as if she intentionally defied the authority of the Capital that she and Peeta will need to prove that their displays of affection in the arena were sincere. Embarking on the Capital’s cruel Victory Tour, Katniss slowly begins to recognize the role she has played in the growing unrest.
Though Catching Fire is somewhat slower paced than its predecessor, the intensity never quits. I found myself having to periodically stop reading and take a break, but my curiosity with how the book would end kept drawing me back to the story. I was particularly enthralled with how Collins gave readers glimpses into the lives of former victors, and the impact the games had on each of them. Additionally, I found a growing appreciation for Katniss as the ultimate flawed heroine who struggles as the reluctant symbol of a burgeoning insurgence. And with the 75th Hunger Games, Collins creation of new surprises doesn’t fail to keep her readers on the edge of their seats.
Once again, I find myself waiting for the next installment of the Hunger Games Trilogy. Wonder what I have to do to get an ARC of the third book????
- Location:my favorite corner
- Mood:
contemplative
Pages: 384
Age Group: Young Adult
Summary (adapted from book cover):
While skipping out of school to play an Alternative Reality Game (ARG), 17 year old Markus and his friends find themselves caught at the center of a terrorist attack on San Francisco. Apprehended by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Markus and his friends are interrogated and tortured. Upon his release, Markus finds that his city has become a police state and that his world has been changed forever. Can a 17 year old computer hacker and his friends fight back against the DHS and the sweeping paranoia of a community and bring about a change? Just maybe…
Before anyone says “I’m not into stories about computer geeks”, I want to challenge you to give this a shot. I consider myself reasonably computer savvy by way of the average computer user. However elevate it to the level of techno-babble, and my eyes glaze over and my head spins. Yet, author Cory Doctorow does a great job in making the story enjoyable for geeks and non-geeks. Though I questioned the extensive technical explanations from the story’s teen narrator in the early chapters, I quickly realized that I would likely be lost without them and felt free to skim the explanations about things that I had a better grasp of.
Doctorow’s main character is a likeable 17 year old computer hacker who enjoys hanging out with his friends and playing computer games. Markus finds himself in the wrong place at the wrong time and his responses to the circumstances set off a series of events that will forever change him and his view of the world. As he struggles to battle against the government, his close friends distance themselves from him and he finds a new ally and partner in a 17 year old girl who is his computer equal.
As I read through the story, I felt that the author did a reasonable job with the struggles and choices that Markus has to make. Are all his choices the right or best choices? No. Sometimes his choices actually set into motion a whole series of other events which at times make things worse. And despite questioning the actions and intentions of all adults throughout the story, Markus eventually finds he needs the assistance of his parents and several other adults in order to find the best resolution.
Adult readers will enjoy the references back to Jack Kerouac’s On the Road and comparisons to the late sixties civil rights movement in San Francisco. Additionally, though some may find Markus’ parents’ reactions, particularly his father’s reactions somewhat annoying, I actually thought that given the circumstances that they were justifiable.
Overall, I found the book to be an enjoyable read which held my attention despite a few times when I started to glaze over from the more technical descriptions. I have already recommended the novel to both teens and adults that I know and would continue to recommend it.
- Location:my favorite corner
- Mood:
tired - Music:Panic Switch by Silversun Pickups
One of my favorite memories of reading books series was that my dad would read quite a few of the mystery books with me including all of the Nancy Drew stories. To me this was impressive. First, the books were geared for young girls so that he would be even willing to read one let alone probably 25 books about these teenage girls out solving mysteries was amazing. Second, I am not sure that my dad would have considered himself a book person back then. My father, whom I adore, specialized more in technical stuff and things he could learn by doing. He learned most things from working with his hands and always credited me with having the “book smarts” in the family. Soi, it was fun to grow up together as readers. Passing books back and forth, sharing our favorite passages, and in some ways influencing one another’s reading habits.
We have both long since moved beyond Nancy Drew, but we haven’t moved beyond exchanging books. I remember introducing my father to the Elvis Cole series by Robert Crais. I was so excited a few years later when I saw that Crais was going to be signing books at Vroman’s in Pasadena. It was right before Father’s Day that year and it was my first time attending an author signing (growing up in a small town in CT we never had author signings). Here was an opportunity to get a book signed to me, but I didn’t even think about doing that. I automatically had him sign the book for my father which I then proudly gave to my Dad for Father’s Day.
To this day, I still share books with my dad. I read a lot more novels and a greater variety of genres than my dad but I often find myself browsing the mysteries and crime section in the bookstore looking for just the right series to introduce to him. And even after all these years, we still tend to like many of the same authors and same books.
So in honor of my Dad’s birthday, and since I can’t be with him, I think I’ll go hang out in a bookstore.
Happy Birthday Dad! I love you!
- Location:my favorite corner
- Mood:
relaxed - Music:Good Man by Josh Ritter
Pages: 311
Ages: 9 to 12
Awards: National Book Award Finalist, Newberry Honor Book 2009
When I pick up books that are geared for middle readers (children between the ages of 9 to 12), I try to imagine my students reading the book. Would the cover catch their eye? Will the story speak to them in some untold way? Do the characters look like them? But most importantly would they read this book even if I hadn’t assigned the book?
Many of my students are known as reluctant readers. Most are students who are English Language Learners from homes with limited resources, and few adult reader role-models. Despite their life challenges, these students do want to read. The hurdle I face is finding a story that will draw them in and convince them to keep reading without being told to read. So it was with this in mind that I approached Kathi Appelt’s novelThe Underneath.
My initial impression of the story’s premise was that it was a tale of friendship between some kittens and a hound. The book summary states “An old hound that has been chained up at his hateful owner’s run-down shack, and two kittens born underneath the house, endure separation, danger, and many other tribulations”. So far sounds like a typical children’s book centered on animals. When you flip open the front cover flap, it states “…Appelt spins a harrowing yet keenly sweet tale about the power of love – and its opposite hate – the fragility of happiness and the importance of making good on your promises.” How harrowing can a children’s story be?
Within a few pages of starting the story, the author tells the story of a child who has been severely beaten by his father who then passes out drunk and who’s mother abandon’s him. The child takes his father’s rifle and leaves home. He grows up to be a bitter, unpleasant man who abuses animals, has a penchant for rum, vodka, and gin and a score to settle with a king alligator. After I got over my initial shock of the description of violence and excessive drinking in the first several chapters (this is a children's book), I hoped that the story would improve and I could find several redeeming qualities about the book.
As I continued, I found myself frustrated with the initial pacing of the story and the style of writing. The slow development of characters and the meandering between the tale of a pregnant calico cat who give birth to twin kittens and befriends Ranger, an abused hound dog, and Grandmother Moccasin (an ancient snake shape-shifter), and then Gar Face the violent, abusive owner of Ranger made it difficult to settle into the story. I had to force myself to keep reading and not put the book down. I kept hoping that the book had a redeeming element. Finally about 100 pages into the story, I had become interested enough in the tale of the kittens and the hound and had the basic premise of each of the parallel stories to propel me forward. Yet when I thought about my students, I knew they never would have continued with this book unless I forced them to read it. If a children’s book takes me 100 pages (out of 300 pages) to finally grab my interest in it, then I know my students aren’t going to hang in there long enough to care about what happens to the animals. The sad part is that I am not even sure my 9 year old niece who is a very competent and enthusiastic reader would hang in there for the first 100 pages.
Appelt’s story weaves together the themes of friendship, loyalty, betrayal, anger, abandonment and loss as she works to intertwine the three separate stories into one. However, the story’s heavy narrative and cumbersome prose burdens this allegorical tale, especially at the beginning. Though the ending does have an element of redemption for Grandmother Moccasin and hope for the kittens and hound, it was not enough to balance out the heavy themes and descriptions of all the characters lives and sorrows. The periodic simple pencil drawings of illustrator David Small do little to enhance the story.
Though I am not one to ban or challenge a book because I do believe that children need to be exposed to a variety of topics, this is one book that I would cautiously recommend. I doubt that my students would be shocked to read about physical abuse towards children, or alcoholic parents or even abandonment; their lives are filled with every day realities of abuse and neglect. What the story fails to do is provide enough hope and redemption to balance out such heavy themes as abandonment, and betrayal. Additionally, the descriptive violence against the animals in the book might actually be more troubling to children who tend to care deeply about these creatures.
Despite The Underneath having been given the 2009 Newberry Honor Book Award, I would reluctantly recommend the story and would not encourage my colleagues to use it as part of any mandatory classroom reading list.
Note: This review is a part of a series of book reviews that are posted on the Young Adult Literature Review (YALR) Blog. To check out this review and others you can go to: http://youngadultlitreviewblog.blogspot.c
The folks at YALR also do a series of podcasts that you can find at http://www.yaliteraturereview.com/librar
Happy reading and listening....
- Location:my favorite corner
- Mood:creative
If I write about what I'm reading, then I also have to admit to my guilty pleasure - Young Adult Urban Fantasy Fiction. Pure fun...but there are some amazingly talented writers out in the world of Young Adult fiction, and in my opinion, I think they do a better job than some of the authors in adult fiction of any genre.
Since June, I have read through Daniel Water's Kiss of Life (sequel to Generation Dead); Holly Black's Tithe, Libba Bray's Great and Terrible Beauty; Mary Pearson's The Adoration of Jenna Fox; Neal Shusterman's Dark Fusion Trilogy (Red Rider's Hood, Dread Locks, Ugly Duckling); Victoria Forester's The Girl Who Could Fly; and I'm in the middle of Margaret Peterson Haddix's series The Shadow Children. And some others that I'm not going to mention at this time.
However, my recent gem of a discovery, which I devoured, is Maggie Stiefvater's book Shiver. Shiver is an absolutely touching story that grabs you from the very first pages and refuses to be put down until you are finished with it. A young adult supernatural love story that is mournful and bittersweet and a standout in this genre. I am so excited to hear that Stiefvater is working on a sequel titled "Linger". I won't babble on incessantly about the book - just not my style- but I will say that it has been the best book of the summer and will probably be knocking some other books out of my top ten list. I have already recommended it to about six people and will be continuing to recommend it to anyone else who will listen. Only thing...they have to buy their own copy...I'm not sharing for awhile...I still want to re-read my favorite parts.
So if you see this posting...share with me what you are reading and I challenge you to set your own reading goal for the rest of the summer.
- Location:My favorite corner
- Mood:
energetic
Educators have a skewed sense of the calendar. The end of the year is the middle of the calendar year. I have been on an academic calendar for nearly my whole life. I’m not sure what I would do if I actually had to follow a regular schedule. With that said, teachers and school administrators work our butts off during the school year and truly earn whatever time we get off during the summer.
Today was the last day of the 2008-2009 school year. It will take me awhile to actually unwind, recover, and rejuvenate before the next school year begins. A few nights of 10+ hours of sleep and a couple of days of doing nothing and I begin feeling human again. Summer is a chance to dive into the stack of books that have been waiting for me, or finally get to the piles around the house that need organizing.
At the beginning of the year, the actual calendar year, I promised myself that I would begin exploring some creative outlets and reconnecting with friends. Over the past several months, despite an intense work schedule, I am excited to report that I have made headway with both those areas. I have carved out more opportunities to hang with friends going to plays, movies, museums or other special events. And I have found myself diving into my writing in ways that I have never explored before.
This past weekend I found a way to combine both of my goals. When I attended the UCLA Festival of Books, I discovered this organization named WriteGirl. They pair professional women writers (or those in related fields) with at-risk teen girls. Together the girls and their mentors explore writing in various areas (poetry, songwriting, journalism, fiction and non-fiction) and the results are compiled into an end of the year publication. I became so excited about what this organization is doing that I applied to be a mentor for the 2009-2010 season. I was so thrilled to be accepted. In order to find out more about the organization, I attended their End of the Season Celebration at the Writer’s Guild Theater. The girls and their mentors read some of their writing, people mingled over a light lunch, and everyone has fun. I dragged a couple of my friends to the end of the season celebration for WriteGirl and we were inspired by what we saw and heard. When the 2009-2010 school year arrives, I will be eagerly anticipating this new adventure.
- Location:my favorite chair
- Mood:
peaceful - Music:Wait and See by Brandon Heath
Not to get all "wallow in pity", I am working on goals. I am finding creative outlets. I have picked up my wriitng for the first time in years and finding a joy in it. I am exploring meaningful volunteer opportunities and I am intentionally planning time with friends. When I started this blog, I called it "a journey onward..." and now several months later, I know I haven't arrived but I know that despite the fuzzy mire that the only antidote for this is to keep moving forward. So armed with sticky notes, and a pair of running shoes, I am on continuing on the path to finding clarity and balance.
- Location:Home
- Mood:
cranky - Music:Running up the Hill by Placebo
In addition to books, vendors, presentations, there are a variety of great panels of well known authors. My favorite panel of yesterday was a comprised of several young adult fiction writers. Cecil Castellucci moderated the panel that included Robin Benway, Deb Caletti, Lauren Myracle, and Lisa Yee. What a group of smart, articulate, funny women. If you like YA fiction, I would highly recommend that you check out any of these authors.
Books, fun, friends.....what a great way to spend a Saturday!
- Location:my favorite chair
- Mood:
bouncy - Music:Carry You Home - James Blunt
"Well, there goes my plan for selling them all on ebay," Clary muttered.
"Selling them on what?"
Clary smiled blandly at him, "A mythical place of great magical power.""
— Cassandra Clare (City of Bones)
*** No Spoilers – Read Freely***
Some women love shoes. I love books. Whereas some people can shop for clothes for hours, I can get lost in a book store for hours a habit that drive friends of mine crazy. I have always thought that my retirement career would be working in a bookstore, a children’s bookstore. In fact, I have had a love affair with books since second or third grade when I discovered chapter books and could actually read them with understanding. And series books were near to heaven for me. The Chronicles of Narnia, Nancy Drew, Little House on the Prairie just to name a few. I loved disappearing between the pages of a book, imagining myself in whatever time or place that the book was set in and assuming the role of one of the characters. When the series came to the end, there was a terrible sadness like a best friend had moved away.
As a child, I could devour one or two books a day and by middle school I was moving into adult literature and read “Gone With the Wind” in a weekend. As an adult my love of books has remained but my time to get lost between the cover of a book became limited. When I open a book, I am a little like a drug addict. I can’t stop. I’ll tell myself “Oh, just one more chapter” and five chapters later I’m still reading. Work, errands, chores are all neglected and even sleep is sacrificed. I have had to have a friend hide a book if I started one when I didn’t truly have the time to read it. When the last Harry Potter book arrived on my doorstep, I purposely cleared everything on my calendar for that day and read it until I was finished (about 14 hours after cracking open the cover). On long plane rides, I have to take at least 2 books of at least 500 pages each in length in order to still have something to read.
Though I read my share of adult fiction, there is still something about books written for children or young adults that call to me. My current obsession is a new trilogy called the Mortal Instruments Series by Cassandra Clare. The first book is “City of Bones” followed by “City of Ashes” and concludes with “City of Glass”. If I had had 3 days absolutely free I could have finished the series in that amount of time. Unfortunately work and life got in the way and it took me a week to do a first read of the series. I already know I will return and read parts of it over and over again. It falls in the Young Adult/Urban Fantasy category which is probably my favorite guilty pleasure of all time.
In the Mortal Instrument (TMI) series, the author, Cassandra Clare, created a beautiful, edgy world with complex and flawed characters that jump off the page and into your life. She makes you care. She makes you laugh. She makes you want to read more. Inspired by the people and places of Manhattan, the majority of the series takes place in New York. Old world fantasy is intertwined with present day trends, styles, and vernacular. Body art or tattoos are used for healing and protection. Secrets. Love Triangles. Adventure. Battles. What more can you ask for?! Hmmm…some more time to read.
- Location:Living room
- Mood:
lazy - Music:It Means Nothing by Stereophonics
For whatever reason, I did not watch “Akeelah and the Bee” when it first came out but it has been sitting on my cue on Netflix forever. But then again, it is not unusual for me to see a movie several years after it is released. Recently, I have begun selecting movies off my cue to watch with a friend and/or her family. When my friend’s eight year old heard that we were watching the movie, she piped up and asked to watch it with us. Hence, a family movie night was planned.
Living in the Los Angeles area and being a principal of an urban elementary school and trying to help prepare students for spelling bees, this movie spoke to me at a very basic level. I was really touched by the story that Director/writer Doug Atchison wove about a young girl in living in South Los Angeles who goes on to compete in the Scripps National Spelling Bee. He did a magnificent job of capturing some of the realities of life for students. So many of my students have incredible potential but their life circumstances make it nearly impossible to overcome. There is a lack of understanding or support at home for academic accomplishment, peer pressure deters promising students from intellectual pursuits, and lack of funding limits enrichment opportunities.
Recently my fourth through sixth graders competed in our District’s Math Field Day competition. I was proud of the four medals that they won. However the more affluent schools in our District won 24 out of 36 potential medals. They accomplish this not because they are smarter than the students in my school but because the environment supports them. In affluent schools, the parents inquire about the selection process for the teams, and partner with the school staff to provide math field day clubs and practice sessions. What the students from the elite school may lack in intrinsic motivation is more than compensated for by the support, encouragement, and structure provide to them by their parents. In our case, students show up during their lunch period or after school because they are motivated not because parents required it of them. My students work around obstacles that the other students do not face in order to study, practice and memorize information that they will need to be successful. Even the simple task of arriving on time for the math competition can be a challenge. They don’t drive and they can’t control the chaos of the morning. So the 4 medals won by my students are often more precious than the multitude of medals won by the other students.
Unlike real life, the movie is able to conquer all those challenges in a feel good way with a happily ever after ending. Akeelah is able to give her neighborhood and community someone to rally behind and a reason to feel proud. Additionally, her relationship with her mother is strengthened and she gives her hope in the future. And of course, her spelling bee coach not only provides Akeelah with the support and motivation needed to take on this challenge, but she brings healing to the broken part of his life as well. And I hope that if I share parts of this movie with my students that they may also receive some much needed inspiration to dream and go after those dreams.
- Location:my favorite chair
- Mood:
content - Music:Rubberband Man by the Spinners
“I guess this is just another lost cause, Mr. Paine. All you people don't know about lost causes. Mr. Paine does. He said once they were the only causes worth fighting for. And he fought for them once, for the only reason any man ever fights for them; because of just one plain simple rule: 'Love thy neighbor.'... And you know that you fight for the lost causes harder than for any other. Yes, you even die for them.” – Jefferson Smith (Jimmy Stewart) in “Mr. Smith Goes to Washington” (1939)
I just got back from a whirlwind trip to Sacramento. This has become my annual trek. As with many professional organizations, a day is designated to descend on the capital and make your voice heard. When I was a child, watching the news on television or seeing TV shows or movies of politicians made the whole world of government seem surreal. Lobbying seemed like a “dirty” word and visiting legislators was something others did. And I really wasn't sure it made a difference. So four years ago when I had my first opportunity to advocate on behalf of education in the state capital, I thought it might be a good experience. I just planned on tagging along and listen to veteran educators converse about topics that though impacted me, I didn’t always feel I understood.
Our professional organization did a great job of preparing us with a briefing on the talking points, key terms, bills, and tips for the process. I was surprised that in the first meeting or two with various Senators and Assemblypersons that our senior members would turn to me for a story or an example of how a bill if passed could impact us at the site level. The day wore on and the stories came easier and the ability to answer questions with solid answers was like second nature. What shocked me was that many of the legislators and their staffers really were interested in what we had to share and often times had really good questions.
Since then, I have looked forward to and almost eagerly anticipated another visit. Over time, I was becoming the experienced voice and sometime lead. And I had learned that a well planned message really could make a difference. However, this year, I knew that even the legislators who had been friends of education might not really be able to assist us. Once again, we had our talking points and kept our message focused. We knew that asking for money with an $8 billion dollar deficit would be futile. But we did find messages to share, concerns to voice, and even some possible solutions. We were able to discuss proposed bills that did not have a cost, and put our heads together about other issues that might result in some new legislation. And once again, I came away thankful for the political respresentatives our city and school has. Men and women who understand and support education. Yet, despite the wonderful support we have, there are others that don't feel the same way and the message needs to continue to be spread. With term limits, our voice and stories need to be continuously shared lest they be forgotten. And though things sometimes feel like a lost cause, children are always worth fighting for.
- Location:home
- Mood:
tired
“There are no victims in this classroom.” – Louanne Johnson (Michelle Pfeiffer), Movie – Dangerous Minds, 1995
Note: This entry contains spoilers for the movie - The Class. Do not read if you plan on seeing the movie and don’t want to know the ending.
It is always hard as an educator to go see films that depict how a teacher comes into a failing school or takes on the most challenging class and in just a few months turns it around. As someone who works with challenging students, I know how hard and complicated it really is. For years now, movie-makers have depicted these stories where a passionate teacher usually in a high school setting is assigned the class that no one wants to teach, and with a no nonsense attitude, a dose of humor, and a willingness to challenge the administration or status quo they elicit some kind of change in the lives of their students. Years ago, we saw Sidney Poitier’s passionate and inspiring performance in “To Sir, With Love” as he sought to change the lives of students in the seedier side of London. There was then Edward James Olmos’ portrayal of Jaime Escalante in “Stand and Deliver” as he inspired Latino students to learn math in order to pass the AP Calculus exam. And Michelle Pfeiffer played Louann Johnson in “Dangerous Minds” who seeks to connect and build trust with her inner city students.
Recently a friend of mine suggested that I see the French movie called “The Class” (“Entre les Murs"). She wasn’t sure that I would like it because it was a foreign film with subtitles but since is was about a teacher working with challenging students she recommended it to me. Now, to be fair, I have nothing against foreign films with subtitles if the movie interests me. I just tend not to go to a lot of movies and if I am going to expend the time and money to see a film then I want it to be good or at least really entertaining. So when a teacher friend of mine suggested that we see “The Class”, I took a chance.
For those who haven’t seen the movie or even heard of it, the movie is about François Bégaudeau, a French school teacher, working in a tough multi-cultural section of Paris. It is filmed more like a documentary than a well-crafted story. I had to keep reminding myself that this is a French film and not something that Hollywood had an opportunity to glamorize into a polished piece. As I watched the film, I couldn’t help to think that the students in the classroom could be students in any inner city school in the United States. Some issues are the same no matter where you live. However, something kept eating at me. After the movie, I processed my feelings with my friend. I couldn’t understand whether I felt I was missing something because of the language translation or the culture of school in France vs. the U.S. I think that what I put my finger on was where was the transformation? Maybe it was more like reality than I wanted to see. Maybe even though I laugh at the incredible student transformations romanticized in our American versions, I still want to believe it is possible, that change, miraculous change, can happen for my students as well. I walked out of the theater feeling like the teacher didn’t get it and the students didn’t really grow from their encounter with him. At the end, when the teacher asked the students what they had learned one of the students claimed she read the “Republic” by Socrates. It’s not that she couldn’t have read it, but it felt fake or contrived as a way to bring meaning into the story. It was more heart-wrenching when the final student leaving the class shared emotionally that she was afraid that she had learned nothing and that she didn’t want to be stuck going to a vocational school. The teacher’s attempt to comfort her felt thin and uninspiring.
I guess for me…I sometimes need the glossy Hollywood version of educators making a difference rather than the stark reality that we sometimes lose more students than we care to admit. Regardless of who’s version is truer, I will continue to seek to make a difference for as many students as possible.
- Location:my room
- Mood:
hopeful - Music:My side of the story - Hodges

